Study 4: A social network analysis of influences on residents’ value-based decisions

Methods

To explore the social network influencing residents’ value-based decisions, the authors used a semistructured individual and mini-group interviewing approach and participatory visual mapping. In total, 17 residents across 13 different specialties were interviewed from the southeastern postgraduate medical education and training region of the Netherlands, May–November 2021. Two researchers independently coded the transcribed data using an integrated inductive thematic approach.

Subsequently, social network analysis was used to visualize the results. Results Residents indicated that their value-based decisions were influenced by direct actors who influenced decisions related to patients and indirect actors who shaped decisions related to patients without directly modifying them. Different interaction-aspects (i.e., personal, situational, and institutional) further affected residents’ ability to make value-based decisions.

Thus, residents’ value-based decisions were a product of the interplay between various interactions with actors and different interaction-aspects. Residents defined value-based decisions differently, even within an interview. Conclusions These results suggest residents’ value-based decisions are influenced by a multitude of actors, including hierarchically superior colleagues who can directly alter decisions and patients (and their families) and nurses with whom residents consider it important to maintain good relationships.

In addition, more experienced actors, mainly from the medical and nursing profession, contribute most to learning. Furthermore, residents’ value-based decisions are deeply underpinned by the hidden curriculum. However, many senior physicians may not have received sufficient training in the concept of value-based health care.

Consequently, an approach of formally educating residents in value-based health care will likely have limited effects unless social influences in day-to-day clinical settings reinforce its importance. Relevant documents The interview transcripts can be viewed in ‘InterviewsSocialNetworkAnalysis’.