← Search

Data · dataset · 2012

Just Google It - Digital Research Practices of Humanities Scholars

Listed in DANS Data Station Social Sciences and Humanities and ODISSEI Portal — shown once because both records carry DOI 10.17026/dans-zqm-nnak

The transition from analog to digital archives and the recent explosion of online content offers researchers novel ways of engaging with data.

Description

The crucial question for ensuring a balance between the supply and demand-side of data, is whether this trend connects to existing scholarly practices and to the average search skills of researchers. To gain insight into this process a survey was conducted among nearly three hundred (N= 288) humanities scholars in the Netherlands and Belgium with the aim of finding answers to the following questions: 1) To what extent are digital databases and archives used? 2) What are the preferences in search functionalities 3) Are there differences in search strategies between novices and experts of information retrieval?

Our results show that while scholars actively engage in research online they mainly search for text and images. General search systems such as Google and JSTOR are predominant, while large-scale collections such as Europeana are rarely consulted. Searching with keywords is the dominant search strategy and advanced search options are rarely used.

Read the rest (2 more)

When comparing novice and more experienced searchers, the first tend to have a more narrow selection of search engines, and mostly use keywords. Our overall findings indicate that Google is the key player among available search engines. This dominant use illustrates the paradoxical attitude of scholars toward Google: while transparency of provenance and selection are deemed key academic requirements, the workings of the Google algorithm remain unclear.

We conclude that Google introduces a black box into digital scholarly practices, indicating scholars will become increasingly dependent on such black boxed algorithms. This calls for a reconsideration of the academic principles of provenance and context.

Links

Topics

Inferred from text
Image 65% · Literary studies 72% · Text 75%
Provenance · 2 source records, 17 field assertions
SourceKeyLast seenRaw
DANS Data Station Social Sciences and Humanitiesdoi:10.17026/DANS-ZQM-NNAK12 d agoJSON v1
ODISSEI Portaldoi:10.17026/DANS-ZQM-NNAK9 d agoJSON v1
FieldAssertionExtractorEvidence
concepts[field].anzsrc:group:4705enrichment · ssh datastations nltaxonomy-embedding@1.1.0title+keywords+description (72%)
concepts[field].dataverse_subject:arts-and-humanitiessource · ssh datastations nlconnector:ssh_datastations_nl@1.0.0/subjects
concepts[field].dataverse_subject:arts-and-humanitiessource · portal odissei nlconnector:portal_odissei_nl@1.0.0/subjects
concepts[field].dataverse_subject:social-sciencessource · portal odissei nlconnector:portal_odissei_nl@1.0.0/subjects
concepts[field].dataverse_subject:social-sciencessource · ssh datastations nlconnector:ssh_datastations_nl@1.0.0/subjects
concepts[field].local:field:humanitiesmapping · ssh datastations nlconnector:ssh_datastations_nl@1.0.0/subjects
concepts[field].local:field:humanitiesmapping · portal odissei nlconnector:portal_odissei_nl@1.0.0/subjects
concepts[field].local:field:social-sciencemapping · portal odissei nlconnector:portal_odissei_nl@1.0.0/subjects
concepts[field].local:field:social-sciencemapping · ssh datastations nlconnector:ssh_datastations_nl@1.0.0/subjects
concepts[modality].local:modality:imageenrichment · ssh datastations nlkeyword-concept-rules@1.0.0title+description (65%)
concepts[modality].local:modality:textenrichment · ssh datastations nlkeyword-concept-rules@1.0.0title+description (75%)
created_datesource · ssh datastations nlconnector:ssh_datastations_nl@1.0.0
descriptionsource · ssh datastations nlconnector:ssh_datastations_nl@1.0.0/description
publication_datesource · ssh datastations nlconnector:ssh_datastations_nl@1.0.0
titlesource · ssh datastations nlconnector:ssh_datastations_nl@1.0.0/name
updated_datesource · ssh datastations nlconnector:ssh_datastations_nl@1.0.0
version_labelsource · ssh datastations nlconnector:ssh_datastations_nl@1.0.0